Some Sparkly Speculation on a Rolling Stone Cover
To keep it kinda, sorta, a marketing or branding discussion, as well as a sales one.
My take: Lambert on the cover of Rolling Stone is not meant to influence rock music buyers or radio programmers--it's meant to sell the issue to fans of the celebrity, just as it is when RS puts the Jonas Brothers, the Gossip Girls or the stars of the Hills on the cover (which they've all been in the last year)
Actual rock consumers are not the ones looking at baby and kindegarten pictures of Adam Lambert (weirdly *fannish* stuff to be running), nor all in a flutter about the Coming Out When He Was Not In.
Rock Radio DJs aren't out there cuddling the issue in their lap and saying OMG, he went to Burning Man! He's done drugs! Yet so witty and he has great parents! And who does his hair? He's DEFINITELY going on the air as SOON as we get that record!!! This whole thing is for people who already love the sparkly dude.
If this were really about trying to acquire new fans or influence consumers who buy a lot of new music, they'd be maybe running a profile now and aim for a cover story the month his record comes out. By blowing their whole wad now, six months before an album drops, I guess maybe they're trying to new ways to hype up the television fans and keep up a hot level of obsession and investment until the music comes out. Some show watchers have always speculated that 19E wants to get back to the Clay/Reuben days when more of the TV audience bought the follow up product and they didn't *have* to rely on breaking through to the general audience via radio as much.
It's the TV show fans who believe that Adam having a cover on Rolling Stone makes him more real. It's not, for example, causing new people to run out and buy his show stuff on iTunes. The ones who care have it already. I have a feeling that 19E/RCA do already have what they hope to be a big hit single already lined up, which they will drop maybe in the summer, following the plan for last year's Crush, or the UK's Leona Lewis, who made almost all her sales off one huge pop single. But I'd be surprised if it's not a pop tune.
As a consumer who enjoyed the AI show this year more as a show, liking differing members of the ensemble during the year, including Lambert, Allen and Iraheta, I'm finding the post-show celebrity mania a turn off. I don't dislike the guy, I just find my interest waning.
Of course, I'm not objective, because I'm a fan of last year's guy and I've liked many other artists on the show. And also I like and buy a lot of new music, making a lot of what he says about music (being a rock star is about dressing up? His hero is Madonna?) sound really . . . kind of lame. Er, should just say, not for me.
Kinds seems like the whole "we can MAKE him happen" thing that went on during the show. We won't know if that tactic works until six months from now when albums drop . . .
Delicious
Digg
Reddit
Magnoliacom
Newsvine
Facebook
Google
Yahoo
Comments for this Blog post
Good point!
About Taylor Swift! She's actually got a much stronger act then most of her teen peers, but her audience is overwhelmingly kids and young women. Like the Jo Bro cover, I think the RS strategy is to put out some covers that will cause a lot of fans of the individual celebrity to run out and buy that one issue, and hope that their core readership of college age to 40 something rock listeners will stick with them for their other articles.
There are definitely many interesting, funny, and well-told parts of Lambert's story . . . but the huge accompanying media onslaught, the packaging it up with videos and making of and family pictures seem totally pitched to (primarily) invested female fans from the show. One of the biggest evidences of this is that on general sites, you get a ton of circular comments that say essentially, the music he puts out does not matter, since celebrity=success and everything he does is guaranteed win.
What that buys them from general music buying audiences . . . whether the hype can sustain itself till year end . . . remains to be seen.
Of course, I'm a bit of a hypocrite. I've loved every bit of media attention David Cook ever got . . . but he happens to be a guy who speaks primarily about music . . . so I can justify that it's always about the man AND the music. I think we're influenced too by seeing Cook work so hard for every piece of success, and often be underestimated. So the attempt to push the "AL's already the biggest star ever over the musicians who have released albums that sold millions" is bound to sting. A bit.
--
kaydeecee
You Forgot Taylor Swift...
She was also on the cover in the last year. She undoubtedly sells magazines (and albums), but she's not rock by any stretch of the imagination. Rolling Stone doesn't have much "rock cred" with me- they've clearly sold out!
I thought the part where Adam talked about wanting to look like his favorite stars/play dress up, was weird too. I enjoyed him on AI, but he's getting to the point of over-saturation now. I am fascinated by the fact that they had him go on and on about sex and his drug use in the RS article. Not unusual subjects for RS, but he was unusually candid for someone just off of AI. Adam kept it clean through the whole season, he's not a loose cannon. This is clearly part of his marketing strategy. I guess he gets to be the edgiest, most exhibitionist Idol.
--
CathyM-K
It's easy when it's done being hard. (Therapy/ Axium)
All that.
Yep to all you wrote. And I have to admit I've been so turned off by all the "rockgod" and "rockstar" talk since I see no real rock in him at all - he seems like pop guy from all I've heard him sing and say. Although, my favorite perf with him was the Kiss one, but that was more because I loved Kiss music as a kid. It would have been just as fun without Adam on the stage for me. No matter... all I know is I'm not a fan of his voice or stage presence or fashion or anything else. He seems like a nice guy though...so hopefully all these ridiculous expectations set for him by his fans and the media don't end up causing him pain.
And yeah, I'll be pissed if he gets a free ride onto rock radio when DC has been slogging it out in the trenches for the past decade. Nothing against AL, but more because I think DC really deserves it.
--
Brisblondie~
Yep. That's 19E's doing...A. Lambert is not going to be the IT from AI
On the heel of season 7, because of the lack of any contestant who is a well-rounded artist as David Cook , (who, by the way, broke the show with his great vocal chop, fantastic musicianship, charisma as well as good look), 19E couldn't just sit there and risk losing too much of their viewership on idol 08. Hence all the drama and the emphasis on Glaming it up for Lambert. It's a shame that the American public bought it and ate it up. Sigh.
I actually doubt that AL will be much at all. Compared with him, Kris Allen has much more of a chance to have longevity in the business. But like someone said on the IdolChatter comment part, "Kris Allen is a poor man's David Cook."
That's how it is.
Amen!
I agree 100% with everything you've said here!